patching...
Update: Got a new smartphone? Get the Patch App! http://farmingdale.patch.com/mobile
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Village of Farmingdale Water Authority Search Continues

A firm will help the board analyze proposals from water districts.

 

The Village of Farmingdale Board of Trustees is continuing to explore handing over control of its water supply by hiring outside consultants to help analyze the proposals.

At Monday night's board meeting, Mayor George Starkie said that both the Bethpage Water District and Suffolk County Water Authority have expressed interest.

"We're hiring an outside agency to help us," Starkie said. "It's getting very difficult to decide, like comparing an apple and an orange. One would require a tax line to bond the upgrades and one just a flat rate."

The board approved the hiring of Guastella Associates, a Massachusetts-based consulting firm, and for their services provided to not exceed $9,000.

"Their whole mainstay is water," Starkie said. "They have an incredible resume, they are experts in this industry."

For about two years, the Village of Farmingdale has been shopping around for an outside source to help run the water supply. Mayor George Starkie presented some options, including a proposal from the Suffolk County Water Authority, at the December board meeting. Benefits of handing over control are updated water technology and savings for residents, the board says.

    The Suffolk County Water Authority deal would require legislation from Albany to happen and if chosen, Farmingdale will be the first Nassau County municipality to work with the Suffolk Authority.

    The village board also discussed the Suffolk Authority's recent evaluation of the water infrastructure.

    "Both water companies are curious what they are getting into," Starkie said. "We know that for every three gallons of water we pump we are only billing for two, there is a known gap. It's a package deal, the companies would be on the hook to fix it, so they are looking at their risks and asking questions, which they should."

    Do you support this initiative by the village? Tell us in the comments.

    Related Topics: Bethpage Water District, Mayor George Starkie, Suffolk COunty Water Authority, Village Board, Village Hall, Village of Farmingdale, and Water Authority

    James M.

    1:03 pm on Tuesday, February 7, 2012

    Stupid Question.

    A. Why are we using a Massachusetts firm and not a local firm? It's really hard to say support your local businesses when the gov't doesn't support them.

    B. Why are we using a consultant to review this? Are the people within the Water Authority unqualified to make this assessment? Why isn't the Commissioner and his staff doing this?

    Reply

    Amanda Fiscina

    1:54 pm on Tuesday, February 7, 2012

    Hi James, Mayor Starkie addressed your first question at the meeting Monday night: the firm specializes in handling water contracts like this and was recommended by another municipality on LI

    Reply

    George

    10:37 am on Sunday, February 12, 2012

    Hi James
    The Boards concerns were many. This is not as simple as you might think.
    If we were to use a local firm could they be unbiased in their analysis? Many of these local firms work for other water districts that have made it very clear they don't want Suffolk County water operating in Nassau. Then the complexities of a flat rate vs a new tax line and lower rates had to be analized today and over a 30 year time frame. To make it even more interesting the village has 4 different rates based on amount of water used. The compeating proposals have a very different effect on those rate
    structures. The report is due in a couple of weeks and it will be posted on the Village web site with both SCWA and Bethpage proposals. Will be a great read!

    Reply

    Leave a comment